Universitas Scholarium — A Community of Scholars Log In
Tutorial Course

BUS 1300 · Why Incumbents Lose: The Innovator's Dilemma

Led by Christensenian Disruption Simulacrum

BUS 1300 · Why Incumbents Lose: The Innovator's Dilemma: course card
1 module · ~30 minutes Accounting & Business Updated June 2026

About this course

A thirty-minute working session with the Christensenian Disruption Simulacrum on the question Clayton Christensen put at the centre of strategic thinking with The Innovator's Dilemma in 1997: why do well-managed incumbents, doing the right thing by their best customers, get unseated by upstarts with worse products?

The course is built around a real business you bring with you and one suspected disruption you want to stress-test. Christensen's argument is structural: the same disciplines that make incumbents great at sustaining innovation make them rationally allocate resources away from disruptive threats until those threats arrive in the mainstream and it is too late to respond. The thirty minutes are spent making that structural account concrete enough to apply.

This course sits in the marketing strand and completes a triptych. It follows BUS 1100 (the Ogilvian Persuasion Simulacrum on writing copy that sells) and BUS 1200 (the Levittian Imagination Simulacrum on marketing myopia). Where Levitt asks what business you are really in from the customer's point of view, Christensen asks which entrant you should be afraid of from the foothold and resource-allocation point of view.

If you found this course useful, consider becoming a patron and supporter. Support Universitas Scholarium →

Why Incumbents Lose:…1
  1. Module 1

    Why Incumbents Lose: The Innovator's Dilemma

    Led by Christensenian Disruption Simulacrum

    The question

    A working session built around your business and one disruption you suspect is brewing. The first sub-unit walks Christensen's central paradox — the well-managed incumbent, listening to its best customers, is exactly the firm unseated by an upstart with a worse product. The second distinguishes the two routes by which disruption arrives, low-end footholds (minimills against integrated steel) and new-market footholds (PCs creating computing where there was none), and separates them from sustaining innovation, which incumbents predictably win. The third applies the diagnostic to your own business: name a potential disruptor, classify the foothold, and identify the resource-allocation pull that would make ignoring it rational right up to the point at which it is too late.

    Outcome

    You leave with one suspected disruption classified against Christensen's framework — sustaining or disruptive, low-end or new-market — and a named resource-allocation pull that would otherwise make your organisation rational in ignoring it.

    Sub-units

    1. ○ 1.1 Why "Good Management" Loses
    2. ○ 1.2 Two Routes of Disruption
    3. ○ 1.3 Diagnose Your Own Position