Universitas Scholarium — A Community of Scholars Log In

Abecedaria Press · Money

Lesson 25

When Compound Interest Works Against You

To the Teacher

Get these things ready before the lesson:

  • the pupils' exercise books with Fatuma's table from Lessons 23 and 24
  • chalk and the blackboard
  • an exercise book, a ruler, and a pen or pencil for each pupil

Time: about 50 minutes. If your pupils find the sums hard, do Exercises 3A and 4 in a second meeting.

In this lesson the pupils learn four things:

  1. Compound interest makes a debt grow, in the same way as savings.
  2. At 10 in every 100 each month, a debt doubles in about 7 months.
  3. Some loans are cheap, and some loans are expensive.
  4. Pay the most expensive debt first.

What you must know before you teach. Read this part two times. Do not read it to the pupils.

The table of Lesson 23 works for a debt too. A moneylender charges Musa 10 in every 100 each month. Musa borrows $100 and pays nothing. So the interest goes on top of the debt, and next month Musa owes interest on the interest. After 6 months he owes $177.

The numbers are the same as Fatuma's savings: 110, 121, 133, 146, 161, 177. But Fatuma's rate was for each year. Musa's rate is for each month. Fatuma waited 7 years for her money to double. Musa's debt doubles in about 7 months.

After 12 months Musa owes about $314, more than three times the loan. If the pupils fill 12 rows with the rule, they get $316. The small difference comes from the rounding. Both answers show the same thing.

Real banks pay savers much less than 10 in every 100 each year. Some lenders charge even more than 10 in every 100 each month. Some charge for each week. Teach the pupils to ask two questions: "How much interest?" and "For each week, month or year?"

What a loan costs. Many lenders do not say a rate. They say only, "Take $100. Pay $30 every week for 4 weeks." Then add up all the payments, and take away the money that you get. The answer is what the loan costs. Here it is $120 − $100 = $20. Some lenders keep a part at the start. They say "Borrow $100", but they give only $90. The loan is the money in your hand, $90. If you pay back $100, that loan costs $10. Compare two loans by what each one costs, for the same time.

A loan is expensive when its rate is high. A loan is cheap when its rate is low. A loan from family with no interest is the cheapest. A savings group also charges interest, but its members share that interest at the share-out (Lesson 21).

Musa must pay every debt as he promised (Lesson 19). When he has extra money, he pays the most expensive debt first. Do not look at the size of the debt; look at the rate. Some pupils do not pay interest because of their faith. This lesson still shows them why a debt with interest can grow so fast.

Begin the Page

To the Teacher: do this at the start of every lesson. Write the lesson title and the date on the board. Each pupil starts a new page in the exercise book. The pupils write the lesson title at the top and underline it with a ruler. Under it they write the date.

The Talk

Teach in these steps. Read the T lines aloud. The P lines show the answers to expect.

  1. Draw a table with the columns MONTH · AT THE START · INTEREST · AT THE END. Write above it: Musa borrows $100 from a moneylender. The rate is 10 in every 100 each month. Musa pays nothing.

T. How much interest does Musa owe after the first month?
P. $10. He owes $110.

T. In month 2, is the interest on $100 or on $110?
P. On $110. The interest is $11. He owes $121.

  1. Fill months 3 to 6 with the pupils, with the rule from Lesson 23.
MONTHAT THE STARTINTERESTAT THE END
110010110
211011121
312112133
413313146
514615161
616116177

T. Look at the numbers. Where did we see them before?
P. In Fatuma's savings table.

T. Fatuma's money doubled in about 7 years. How long does Musa's debt take?
P. About 7 months. His rate is for each month, not each year.

  1. Say: "After one year, Musa owes about $314. He borrowed only $100."

T. Is this loan cheap or expensive?
P. It is very expensive.

T. A lender says, "Take $100. Pay $30 every week for 4 weeks." What does Musa pay in all?
P. $120. 30, 60, 90, 120.

T. He got $100. What does the loan cost him?
P. $20. 120 take away 100 is 20.

  1. Write Musa's three debts on the board.
LENDERMUSA OWESRATE
his brother$200no interest
the savings group$1005 in every 100 each month
the moneylender$10010 in every 100 each month

T. Musa has $100 extra this month. Which debt does he pay first?
P. The moneylender. That debt is the most expensive.

T. The debt to his brother is the biggest. Why is it last?
P. It has no interest. It does not grow.

If a pupil says, "Musa can forget his brother's debt": say, "No. Musa pays every debt as he promised. Only the extra money goes to the most expensive debt."

If a pupil says, "Musa can borrow from a second moneylender to pay the first one": say, "Then he owes interest to two lenders. Borrow to pay a debt only with a plan, and only from a cheaper lender" (Lesson 19).

If a pupil says, "Musa cannot pay at all": say, "He must talk to the lender early, before the debt grows" (Lesson 19).

New Words

To the Teacher: write the three words on the board. Say each word and its meaning. The pupils copy the words into their exercise books.

WordMeaning in this book
chargeTo ask a person to pay an amount. The lender charges 10 in every 100.
expensiveIt costs a lot of money.
cheapIt costs little money.

To the Teacher: the cost of a loan is its interest. So a loan with a high rate is expensive. In this book cheap means only "it costs little money". It does not mean "bad".

Learn by Heart

Compound interest makes an unpaid debt grow fast.

Pay the most expensive debt first.

To the Teacher: write the two sentences on the board. Leave them there until the end of the lesson. The pupils say them aloud, all together, three times. Then each pupil says them alone.

Exercise 1. Answer aloud.

To the Teacher: ask each question. The pupils answer aloud. Nobody writes.

  1. Musa borrows $100 at 10 in every 100 each month. What does he owe after 1 month?
  2. Why does Musa's debt grow faster every month?
  3. Musa's debt doubles in about 7 months. Fatuma's savings take 7 years. Why?
  4. What is an expensive loan?
  5. You have three debts and some extra money. Which debt do you pay first?
  6. Musa cannot pay. Who must he talk to?

Exercise 2. Fill the debt table.

To the Teacher: write the facts and the model row on the board. Read the facts aloud two times. The pupils draw the table and fill 4 rows. Then they answer the question.

Facts: Halima borrows $300 from a moneylender. The moneylender charges 10 in every 100 each month. Halima pays nothing for 4 months.

Model.

MONTHAT THE STARTINTERESTAT THE END
130030330

Question: After 4 months, how much interest does Halima owe in all?

Exercise 3. Which loan is cheaper?

To the Teacher: write the model and the six pairs on the board. Read each pair aloud. The pupils write the number and A or B.

Model. A: 10 in every 100 each month. B: 10 in every 100 each year. → B. The number is the same, but B is for a whole year.

  1. A: 5 in every 100 each month. B: 10 in every 100 each month.
  2. A: a loan from a brother, no interest. B: a loan from a moneylender, 10 in every 100 each month.
  3. A: 10 in every 100 each week. B: 10 in every 100 each month.
  4. A: 2 in every 100 each month. B: 20 in every 100 each month.
  5. A: borrow $100, pay back $150 after one month. B: borrow $100, pay back $110 after one month.
  6. A: borrow $100, pay back $120 after one year. B: borrow $100, pay back $120 after one month.

Exercise 3A. What does the loan cost?

To the Teacher: write the model and the six items on the board. The pupils add up all the payments. Then they take away the money that the borrower gets. The answer is what the loan costs.

Model. Borrow $100. Pay $30 every week for 4 weeks. → 30 + 30 + 30 + 30 = 120. 120 − 100 = 20. The loan costs $20.

  1. Borrow $200. Pay $60 every week for 4 weeks.
  2. Borrow $100 from a brother. Pay $25 every week for 4 weeks.
  3. Borrow $500. Pay $150 every month for 4 months.
  4. Borrow $300. Pay $110 every month for 3 months.
  5. The lender says, "Borrow $100." He gives you only $90. You pay back $100 after one month.
  6. Loan A: borrow $100, pay $30 every week for 4 weeks. Loan B: borrow $100, pay $26 every week for 4 weeks. Which loan is cheaper?

Exercise 4. Which debt first?

To the Teacher: write the model and the two lists of debts on the board. The pupils write the lenders in order: the first debt to pay, then the second, then the third.

Model. Musa's debts (from the Talk) → 1. the moneylender · 2. the savings group · 3. his brother.

Peter's debts:

LENDERPETER OWESRATE
the shop$50no interest
a moneylender$20010 in every 100 each month
the savings group$1005 in every 100 each month

Grace's debts:

LENDERGRACE OWESRATE
her sister$300no interest
a bank$5002 in every 100 each month
a moneylender$10020 in every 100 each month

Exercise 5. Write the missing word.

To the Teacher: write the six sentences on the board, with a line for each missing word. The pupils copy each sentence and write the missing word.

  1. The moneylender ______ 10 in every 100 each month.
  2. A loan with a high rate is ______.
  3. A loan with a low rate is ______.
  4. At 10 in every 100 each month, a debt ______ in about 7 months.
  5. Pay the most ______ debt first.
  6. Compound interest is interest on the ______ too.

Exercise 6. Copy in your best handwriting.

The pupils copy the two sentences from the board (Learn by Heart). They write each sentence two times.

To the Teacher: the pupils use the handwriting from Learning to Write, or the joined handwriting from Cursive if they know it. Look at every page. Check three things: a capital letter at the start, a full stop at the end, and the spelling.

After the Lesson

To the Teacher: Lesson 26 is a review of Part Five. Ask the pupils to bring their exercise books with all their tables from Lessons 20 to 25. Ask each pupil to think of one savings goal.

Answers (for the teacher)

Exercise 1. 1. $110. 2. Each month he owes interest on the interest too. 3. Her rate is for each year. His rate is for each month. 4. A loan with a high rate. It costs a lot of money. 5. The most expensive debt: the debt with the highest rate. 6. The lender. He must talk to the lender early (Lesson 19).

Exercise 2.

MONTHAT THE STARTINTERESTAT THE END
130030330
233033363
336336399
439940439

Halima owes $139 of interest in all (439 − 300 = 139). Month 4: cover the 9 in 399 → 39. The 9 is 5 or more, so add 1 → 40.

Exercise 3. 1. A (5 is less than 10) 2. A (no interest) 3. B (the week rate comes about 4 times in a month) 4. A (2 is less than 20) 5. B (loan B costs $10; loan A costs $50) 6. A (the same $20, but for a whole year)

Exercise 3A.

  1. 60 + 60 + 60 + 60 = 240. 240 − 200 = 40. The loan costs $40.
  2. 25 + 25 + 25 + 25 = 100. 100 − 100 = 0. The loan costs $0. It has no interest.
  3. 150 + 150 + 150 + 150 = 600. 600 − 500 = 100. The loan costs $100.
  4. 110 + 110 + 110 = 330. 330 − 300 = 30. The loan costs $30.
  5. You get $90 in your hand. You pay back $100. 100 − 90 = 10. The loan costs $10.
  6. B. Loan A costs $20 (120 − 100). Loan B costs $4 (26 + 26 + 26 + 26 = 104; 104 − 100 = 4). Both are for 4 weeks.

Number 5: the lender says "$100", but the loan is the money in your hand. Always count it.

Exercise 4.

  • Peter: 1. a moneylender · 2. the savings group · 3. the shop
  • Grace: 1. a moneylender · 2. a bank · 3. her sister

Grace: the bank debt is the biggest, but its rate is low. The moneylender's debt is the smallest, but its rate is the highest. Look at the rate, not the size.

Exercise 5. 1. charges · 2. expensive · 3. cheap · 4. doubles · 5. expensive · 6. interest