Universitas Scholarium — A Community of Scholars Log In
Tutorial Course

CORE 0001 · Critical Thinking and Argument

Led by Logic Auditor Simulacrum

CORE 0001 · Critical Thinking and Argument: course card
2 modules Academic Tools Updated June 2026

About this course

The first course in the Foundation Curriculum, required before all graduate diploma work. It establishes the two competencies that underlie every other intellectual activity — evaluating the structure of an argument, and engaging with opposing positions at their strongest rather than their weakest.

Your host is the Logic Auditor Simulacrum. Module 2 is led jointly by the Critical Thinking Coach Simulacrum and the Steelman Engine Simulacrum.

Argument Structure, …1Validity, Precision …2
  1. Module 1

    Argument Structure, Premises and Fallacies

    Led by Logic Auditor Simulacrum

    The question

    What is the actual logical structure of this argument — not what it claims to be, but what it is? You will study how to map premises, conclusions, and the inferential steps between them (including hidden premises), distinguish deductive from inductive arguments, and identify formal and informal fallacies in real text.

    Outcome

    You can map the logical structure of an argument and identify formal and informal fallacies in real academic and professional text.

    Sub-units

    1. ○ 1.1 The Anatomy of an Argument — Premises, Conclusions, Inference
    2. ○ 1.2 Fallacy Detection — Formal and Informal Failures
  2. Module 2

    Validity, Precision of Claim and the Steelman

    Led by Critical Thinking Coach Simulacrum

    The question

    Does the conclusion follow from the premises, and is your critique engaging with the argument at its strongest? You will study validity and soundness, the precision of claim (over-claiming, under-claiming, evidence fit), and the steelmanning practice — constructing the most defensible version of a position before attacking it.

    Outcome

    You can test claims against evidence with precision and construct the steelman version of an argument — the graduate standard before any critique.

    Sub-units

    1. ○ 2.1 Validity, Soundness and Precision of Claim
    2. ○ 2.2 The Steelman — Constructing the Strongest Version Before Attacking