Led by John Stuart Mill

About this course
The fifth module turns the paper from how to live to how to live together, and from ethics to political philosophy. Mill, who led the module on utilitarianism, returns as the founding theorist of modern liberalism.
His starting point is a danger peculiar to the democratic age: not the tyranny of kings, long since fenced in, but the tyranny of the majority — exercised not only through law but through the suffocating pressure of mass opinion and custom. Against it Mill sets one principle: society may coerce a competent adult only to prevent harm to others, never for the person's own good, and never merely because others disapprove. The module reconstructs his liberalism as a structure of argument — the harm principle and the difficult line between self-regarding and other-regarding conduct; the famous four-part case that free speech is the very engine of truth; the value of individuality against the despotism of custom; and the limits of state power — and then presses the deep tension at its heart: Mill grounds near-inviolable liberty on utility, yet utility seems always able to override it. That unresolved tension is exactly what the turn to Rawls, in the modules that follow, is meant to address.
The student leaves able to state and assess Mill's liberalism whole, and to see why the basic liberties may need a foundation other than the general happiness. They read Mill's On Liberty and Considerations on Representative Government directly.
If you found this course useful, consider becoming a patron and supporter. Support Universitas Scholarium →
Led by John Stuart Mill
The question
What may a society rightfully do to its members — and what must it leave to them alone? Mill answers with the harm principle: over conduct that concerns only himself, the individual is sovereign, and society may coerce a person only to prevent harm to others, never for the person's own good and never merely because the majority is offended. The module reconstructs his case for this principle, his powerful argument that even false opinions must be free because the contest of ideas is how we hold truth at all, and his defence of individuality against the deadening weight of custom — then asks the hard questions: where does "harming only oneself" end, and can a thinker who grounds liberty on the general happiness really keep liberty safe from being traded away for that happiness?