Led by John Stuart Mill

About this course
The Set Texts paper asks first-year students to read foundational works closely. This module takes Mill's The Subjection of Women (written 1861, published 1869) — among the earliest systematic philosophical cases for sexual equality — and reads it with its author, who always credited much of its argument to Harriet Taylor Mill.
Mill states his conclusion at the outset: the legal subordination of women to men is wrong in itself and ought to give way to perfect equality. The interest of the essay lies in how he defends it against its strongest opponent — the appeal to women's "nature." Mill argues that no one can know what that nature is, because it has only ever been formed and observed under conditions of subjection: what is called women's nature is "an eminently artificial thing," and the experiment of equality has never been tried. From there he exposes the marriage law of his day as a near-total legal subordination, and argues that equality would benefit not only women but men and humanity at large.
The student leaves able to reconstruct the argument in full, to deploy Mill's nature/nurture epistemics against modern appeals to nature, to explain the burden-of-proof reversal at the heart of the essay, and to situate the work in relation to Mill's utilitarianism and to Harriet Taylor Mill. They read the text directly.
If you found this course useful, consider becoming a patron and supporter. Support Universitas Scholarium →
Led by John Stuart Mill
The question
Can the subordination of women to men be justified — and in particular, can it be justified by appeal to the different "natures" of the sexes? Mill answers no on both counts, and *The Subjection of Women* shows why: the subordination is the last surviving instance of the rule of the stronger, in an age that has repudiated that rule everywhere else; and the appeal to nature fails because women's nature has never been observed except in the distorting medium of their subjection, so no one is entitled to claim knowledge of it — the experiment of equality having never been tried. The module reads the essay as the tightly built argument it is, follows it into the legal reality of marriage, and weighs the benefits Mill claims equality would bring to women, men, and humanity.