Universitas Scholarium — A Community of Scholars Log In

← Iānuae Latīnitātis Vestibulum

Iānuae Latīnitātis Vestibulum
Lesson 21
21 of 89 lessons

Lesson 21: Lectiō Ūnētvīcēsima: Dē Comparātīvīs On Comparatives

IĀNUAE LATĪNITĀTIS VESTIBULUM

Lectiō Ūnētvīcēsima: Dē Comparātīvīs

On Comparatives

Prōlogus: Ē Sepulchrō Comēniī

Salvēte, discipulī cārissimī.

Hūcusque adiectīva in gradū positīvō sōlō didicistis: rēs est magna vel parva, bona vel mala, certa vel dubia. Sed mundus nōn sōlum ex oppositīs cōnstat—etiam ex gradibus. Ūna rēs est bona, altera melior, tertia optima. Hoc est modus quō Latīna lingua subtīlitātem iūdiciī exprimit.

Until now you have learned adjectives only in the positive degree: a thing is great or small, good or bad, certain or doubtful. But the world does not consist only of opposites—it also consists of degrees. One thing is good, another better, a third best. This is the way by which the Latin language expresses subtlety of judgment.

Hodiē trēs gradūs comparātiōnis discēmus: positīvum, comparātīvum, et superlātīvum—per exemplum simplicissimum et clārissimum.

Today we shall learn the three degrees of comparison: the positive, the comparative, and the superlative—through the simplest and clearest example.

Ē tenebrīs Lēšnēnsibus, Iōannēs Āmos Comēnius

PARS PRĪMA: VESTIBULUM

Comparātīva — Comparatives

Pars A: Textus Explicātus (Construed Text)

Prīmus The first est is doctus. learned. Secundus The second [est] [is] doctior. more learned. Tertius The third [est] [is] doctissimus. the most learned.

Pars B: Sententiae Alternantēs (Alternating Sentences)

Prīmus est doctus. The first is learned.

Secundus est doctior. The second is more learned.

Tertius est doctissimus. The third is the most learned.

Pars C: Textus Latīnus Sōlus (Latin Text Only)

Prīmus est doctus. Secundus est doctior. Tertius est doctissimus.

Pars D: Nōtae Grammaticae (Grammatical Notes)

I. The Three Degrees of Comparison

Latin adjectives have three degrees (gradūs):

Degree Latin Name Example Meaning Positive gradus positīvus doctus, -a, -um learned Comparative gradus comparātīvus doctior, doctius more learned Superlative gradus superlātīvus doctissimus, -a, -um most learned

II. Regular Formation

For most adjectives of the first and second declension (-us, -a, -um):

Comparative: Remove the ending, add -ior (m./f.) or -ius (n.) -

doctus → doct- → doctior (m./f.), doctius (n.)

Superlative: Remove the ending, add -issimus, -issima, -issimum -

doctus → doct- → doctissimus, -a, -um

III. Declension of the Comparative

The comparative degree declines as a third declension adjective:

Case Masculine/Feminine Neuter Nom. doctior doctius Gen. doctiōris doctiōris Dat. doctiōrī doctiōrī Acc. doctiōrem doctius Abl. doctiōre doctiōre

The plural follows regularly: doctiōrēs (m./f.), doctiōra (n.), etc.

IV. The Superlative Declines Normally

The superlative (doctissimus, -a, -um) declines exactly like a regular first/second declension adjective—like bonus, -a, -um.

V. Comparing Two Things: Quam or Ablative

To express comparison, Latin uses two methods:

With quam (than): -

Secundus est doctior quam prīmus. — The second is more learned than the first.

With the ablative alone (ablative of comparison): -

Secundus est doctior prīmō. — The second is more learned than the first.

VI. Ordinal Numbers (Review)

This lesson introduces ordinal numbers in context:

Ordinal Meaning prīmus, -a, -um first secundus, -a, -um second tertius, -a, -um third

VII. Vocabula Nova (New Vocabulary)

Latīnē Ānglicē Pars Ōrātiōnis doctus, -a, -um learned, taught adjective (also perf. part. of doceō) doctior, doctius more learned comparative adjective, 3rd decl. doctissimus, -a, -um most learned superlative adjective, 1st/2nd decl. prīmus, -a, -um first ordinal numeral, 1st/2nd decl. secundus, -a, -um second ordinal numeral, 1st/2nd decl. tertius, -a, -um third ordinal numeral, 1st/2nd decl. quam than; how conjunction / adverb

PARS SECUNDA: FĀBULA

Trēs Discipulī — The Three Students

Pars A: Textus Explicātus (Construed Text)

In In lūdō the school litterāriō literary quōdam a certain trēs three discipulī students Latīnam Latin linguam the language discēbant. were learning.

Prīmus The first discipulus student erat was puer a boy dīligēns. diligent. Quōtīdiē Every day vocābula vocabulary nova new discēbat he learned et and grammaticam grammar studiōsē studiously exercēbat. he practised. Magister The teacher dīxit said eum that he esse was doctum. learned.

Secundus The second discipulus student erat was puella a girl doctiōr more learned quam than prīmus. the first. Nōn Not sōlum only vocābula vocabulary discēbat did she learn sed but etiam also librōs books Latīnōs Latin legēbat. she read. Magister The teacher dīxit said eam that she esse was doctiōrem more learned quam than prīmum the first discipulum. student.

Tertius The third discipulus student erat was senex an old man quīdam a certain quī who Latīnē in Latin nōn not sōlum only legēbat read sed but etiam also scrībēbat wrote et and loquēbātur. spoke. Dē About historiā history Rōmānā Roman multa many things sciēbat. he knew. Poētās Poets antīquōs ancient memoriter from memory recitāre to recite poterat. he was able. Magister The teacher dīxit said eum that he esse was doctissimum the most learned omnium. of all.

Ōlim One day prīmus the first discipulus student magisterque and the teacher colloquēbantur. were conversing. Prīmus The first discipulus student dīxit said sē that he numquam never tam so doctum learned fore would be quam as tertium the third discipulum. student.

Magister The teacher rīsit. laughed. “Senex “The old man ille,” that,” inquit, he said, “ōlim “once puer a boy erat was sīcut just like tū. you. Nōn Not nātus born est was he doctissimus. the most learned. Prīmō At first erat he was doctus. learned. Deinde Then doctior more learned factus he became est. — Tandem Finally doctissimus.” the most learned.”

“Tempus “Time et and labor,” work,” inquit he said magister, the teacher, “doctiōrem “a more learned person ē from doctō a learned one faciunt. make. Tempus Time et and amor love doctrīnae of learning doctissimum the most learned ē from doctiōre a more learned one faciunt.” make.”

Prīmus The first discipulus student hīs by these verbīs words cōnfirmātus encouraged est. was. Ex From illō that diē day studiōsius more studiously labōrāvit. he worked.

Morāle: The moral: “Nēmō “No one nāscitur is born doctissimus. the most learned. Omnēs All ā from gradū the degree positīvō positive incipiunt.” begin.”

Pars B: Sententiae Alternantēs (Alternating Sentences)

In lūdō litterāriō quōdam trēs discipulī Latīnam linguam discēbant. In a certain literary school, three students were learning the Latin language.

Prīmus discipulus erat puer dīligēns. The first student was a diligent boy.

Quōtīdiē vocābula nova discēbat et grammaticam studiōsē exercēbat. Every day he learned new vocabulary and studiously practised grammar.

Magister dīxit eum esse doctum. The teacher said that he was learned.

Secundus discipulus erat puella doctior quam prīmus. The second student was a girl more learned than the first.

Nōn sōlum vocābula discēbat sed etiam librōs Latīnōs legēbat. She not only learned vocabulary but also read Latin books.

Magister dīxit eam esse doctiōrem quam prīmum discipulum. The teacher said that she was more learned than the first student.

Tertius discipulus erat senex quīdam quī Latīnē nōn sōlum legēbat sed etiam scrībēbat et loquēbātur. The third student was a certain old man who not only read in Latin but also wrote and spoke.

Dē historiā Rōmānā multa sciēbat. He knew many things about Roman history.

Poētās antīquōs memoriter recitāre poterat. He was able to recite ancient poets from memory.

Magister dīxit eum esse doctissimum omnium. The teacher said that he was the most learned of all.

Ōlim prīmus discipulus magisterque colloquēbantur. One day the first student and the teacher were conversing.

Prīmus discipulus dīxit sē numquam tam doctum fore quam tertium discipulum. The first student said that he would never be so learned as the third student.

Magister rīsit. The teacher laughed.

“Senex ille,” inquit, “ōlim puer erat sīcut tū. Nōn nātus est doctissimus.” “That old man,” he said, “was once a boy just like you. He was not born the most learned.”

“Prīmō erat doctus. Deinde doctior factus est. Tandem doctissimus.” “At first he was learned. Then he became more learned. Finally the most learned.”

“Tempus et labor,” inquit magister, “doctiōrem ē doctō faciunt. Tempus et amor doctrīnae doctissimum ē doctiōre faciunt.” “Time and work,” said the teacher, “make a more learned person from a learned one. Time and love of learning make the most learned from a more learned one.”

Prīmus discipulus hīs verbīs cōnfirmātus est. Ex illō diē studiōsius labōrāvit. The first student was encouraged by these words. From that day he worked more studiously.

Morāle: “Nēmō nāscitur doctissimus. Omnēs ā gradū positīvō incipiunt.” Moral: “No one is born the most learned. All begin from the positive degree.”

Pars C: Textus Latīnus Sōlus (Latin Text Only)

In lūdō litterāriō quōdam trēs discipulī Latīnam linguam discēbant.

Prīmus discipulus erat puer dīligēns. Quōtīdiē vocābula nova discēbat et grammaticam studiōsē exercēbat. Magister dīxit eum esse doctum.

Secundus discipulus erat puella doctior quam prīmus. Nōn sōlum vocābula discēbat sed etiam librōs Latīnōs legēbat. Magister dīxit eam esse doctiōrem quam prīmum discipulum.

Tertius discipulus erat senex quīdam quī Latīnē nōn sōlum legēbat sed etiam scrībēbat et loquēbātur. Dē historiā Rōmānā multa sciēbat. Poētās antīquōs memoriter recitāre poterat. Magister dīxit eum esse doctissimum omnium.

Ōlim prīmus discipulus magisterque colloquēbantur. Prīmus discipulus dīxit sē numquam tam doctum fore quam tertium discipulum.

Magister rīsit. “Senex ille,” inquit, “ōlim puer erat sīcut tū. Nōn nātus est doctissimus. Prīmō erat doctus. Deinde doctior factus est. Tandem doctissimus.”

“Tempus et labor,” inquit magister, “doctiōrem ē doctō faciunt. Tempus et amor doctrīnae doctissimum ē doctiōre faciunt.”

Prīmus discipulus hīs verbīs cōnfirmātus est. Ex illō diē studiōsius labōrāvit.

Morāle: “Nēmō nāscitur doctissimus. Omnēs ā gradū positīvō incipiunt.”

Pars D: Nōtae Fābulae (Notes on the Fable)

Pedagogical Theme

The fable embodies Comenius’s principle that all learning is gradual—omnia sponte fluant. No one begins at mastery. The metaphor of the three degrees of comparison becomes a metaphor for life itself: we all begin at the positive degree and, through patience and effort, progress through comparative to superlative.

Grammar Highlights

Ōrātiō Oblīqua (Indirect Statement): -

Magister dīxit eum esse doctum. — The teacher said that he was learned. (acc. + inf.) -

Magister dīxit eam esse doctiōrem. — The teacher said that she was more learned. (acc. + inf.) -

Dīxit sē numquam tam doctum fore. — He said that he would never be so learned. (acc. + inf. with future infinitive fore)

Comparative Constructions: -

doctior quam prīmus — more learned than the first (quam + nominative) -

doctiōrem quam prīmum discipulum — more learned than the first student (quam + accusative, matching case) -

doctissimum omnium — most learned of all (superlative + genitive of the whole)

Comparative Adverb: -

studiōsius labōrāvit — he worked more studiously (comparative adverb from studiōsē)

PARS TERTIA: COLLOQUIUM

Magister et Discipulus — Teacher and Student

Pars A: Textus Explicātus (Construed Text)

DISCIPULUS: Magister, Master, quid what est is “comparātīvum”? a “comparative”?

COMĒNIUS: Attendē Pay attention bene. well. Sī If ūnus one discipulus student est is doctus, learned, positīvum the positive habēmus. we have. Rēs The thing ipsa itself sōla alone dēscrībitur. is described.

DISCIPULUS: Hoc This iam already sciō. I know. Omnia All adiectīva the adjectives quae which didicimus we have learned sunt are positīva! positive!

COMĒNIUS: Rēctē! Correct! Nunc Now finge imagine duōs two discipulōs. students. Prīmus The first est is doctus. learned. Secundus The second est is doctior more learned —id —that est, is, magis more doctus learned quam than prīmus. the first. Hic This gradus degree vocātur is called “comparātīvus” “comparative” quia because duās two rēs things comparāmus. we compare.

DISCIPULUS: Intellegō! I understand! Et And “superlātīvus”? the “superlative”?

COMĒNIUS: Superlātīvus The superlative est is gradus the degree summus. highest. Tertius The third est is doctissimus the most learned —nēmō —no one est is doctior more learned quam than ille. he. Superlātīvus The superlative omnēs all aliōs others superat. surpasses.

DISCIPULUS: Quōmodo How hōs these gradūs degrees formāmus? do we form?

COMĒNIUS: Simpliciter! Simply! Ā From rādīce the root adiectīvī of the adjective incipimus. we begin. “Doct-” “Doct-” est is rādīx the root vocis of the word “doctus.” “learned.” Adde Add -ior -ior et and habēs you have comparātīvum: the comparative: doctior. more learned. Adde Add -issimus -issimus et and habēs you have superlātīvum: the superlative: doctissimus. the most learned.

DISCIPULUS: Estne Is it semper always tam so simplex? simple?

COMĒNIUS: Prō For plūrimīs most adiectīvīs, adjectives, ita! yes! Sed But quaedam certain adiectīva adjectives sunt are anomala irregular —nōn —they do not rēgulam the rule sequuntur. follow. Dē About hīs these in in proximā the next lectiōne lesson discēmus. we shall learn.

DISCIPULUS: Possumusne Can we aliud another exemplum example exercēre? practise?

COMĒNIUS: Certē! Certainly! Fēlīx Happy —fēlīcior —happier —fēlīcissimus. —happiest. Fortis Strong —fortior —stronger —fortissimus. —strongest. Longus Long —longior —longer —longissimus. —longest.

DISCIPULUS: Fōrmam The pattern videō! I see! Rādīx Root + -ior + -ior = comparātīvus. = comparative. Rādīx Root + -issimus + -issimus = superlātīvus. = superlative.

COMĒNIUS: Rēctissimē! Most correctly! Hic This ōrdō pattern est is cōnstāns. consistent. Eum It memoriā in memory tenē hold —saepe —often tibi for you ūtilis useful erit. it will be.

DISCIPULUS: Grātiās Thanks tibi to you agō, I give, magister! master!

COMĒNIUS: Hodiē Today doctus learned es. you are. Crās Tomorrow doctior more learned eris. you will be. Mox Soon doctissimus! the most learned!

Pars B: Sententiae Alternantēs (Alternating Sentences)

DISCIPULUS: Magister, quid est “comparātīvum”? STUDENT: Master, what is a “comparative”?

COMĒNIUS: Attendē bene. Sī ūnus discipulus est doctus, positīvum habēmus. Rēs ipsa sōla dēscrībitur. COMENIUS: Pay attention well. If one student is learned, we have the positive. The thing itself alone is described.

DISCIPULUS: Hoc iam sciō. Omnia adiectīva quae didicimus sunt positīva! STUDENT: I already know this. All the adjectives we have learned are positive!

COMĒNIUS: Rēctē! Nunc finge duōs discipulōs. Prīmus est doctus. Secundus est doctior—id est, magis doctus quam prīmus. Hic gradus vocātur “comparātīvus” quia duās rēs comparāmus. COMENIUS: Correct! Now imagine two students. The first is learned. The second is more learned—that is, more learned than the first. This degree is called “comparative” because we compare two things.

DISCIPULUS: Intellegō! Et “superlātīvus”? STUDENT: I understand! And the “superlative”?

COMĒNIUS: Superlātīvus est gradus summus. Tertius est doctissimus—nēmō est doctior quam ille. Superlātīvus omnēs aliōs superat. COMENIUS: The superlative is the highest degree. The third is the most learned—no one is more learned than he. The superlative surpasses all others.

DISCIPULUS: Quōmodo hōs gradūs formāmus? STUDENT: How do we form these degrees?

COMĒNIUS: Simpliciter! Ā rādīce adiectīvī incipimus. “Doct-” est rādīx vocis “doctus.” Adde -ior et habēs comparātīvum: doctior. Adde -issimus et habēs superlātīvum: doctissimus. COMENIUS: Simply! We begin from the root of the adjective. “Doct-” is the root of the word “learned.” Add -ior and you have the comparative: more learned. Add -issimus and you have the superlative: most learned.

DISCIPULUS: Estne semper tam simplex? STUDENT: Is it always so simple?

COMĒNIUS: Prō plūrimīs adiectīvīs, ita! Sed quaedam adiectīva sunt anomala—nōn rēgulam sequuntur. Dē hīs in proximā lectiōne discēmus. COMENIUS: For most adjectives, yes! But certain adjectives are irregular—they do not follow the rule. About these we shall learn in the next lesson.

DISCIPULUS: Possumusne aliud exemplum exercēre? STUDENT: Can we practise another example?

COMĒNIUS: Certē! Fēlīx—fēlīcior—fēlīcissimus. Fortis—fortior—fortissimus. Longus—longior—longissimus. COMENIUS: Certainly! Happy—happier—happiest. Strong—stronger—strongest. Long—longer—longest.

DISCIPULUS: Fōrmam videō! Rādīx + -ior = comparātīvus. Rādīx + -issimus = superlātīvus. STUDENT: I see the pattern! Root + -ior = comparative. Root + -issimus = superlative.

COMĒNIUS: Rēctissimē! Hic ōrdō est cōnstāns. Eum memoriā tenē—saepe tibi ūtilis erit. COMENIUS: Most correctly! This pattern is consistent. Hold it in memory—it will often be useful for you.

DISCIPULUS: Grātiās tibi agō, magister! STUDENT: Thank you, master!

COMĒNIUS: Hodiē doctus es. Crās doctior eris. Mox doctissimus! COMENIUS: Today you are learned. Tomorrow you will be more learned. Soon the most learned!

Pars C: Textus Latīnus Sōlus (Latin Text Only)

DISCIPULUS: Magister, quid est “comparātīvum”?

COMĒNIUS: Attendē bene. Sī ūnus discipulus est doctus, positīvum habēmus. Rēs ipsa sōla dēscrībitur.

DISCIPULUS: Hoc iam sciō. Omnia adiectīva quae didicimus sunt positīva!

COMĒNIUS: Rēctē! Nunc finge duōs discipulōs. Prīmus est doctus. Secundus est doctior—id est, magis doctus quam prīmus. Hic gradus vocātur “comparātīvus” quia duās rēs comparāmus.

DISCIPULUS: Intellegō! Et “superlātīvus”?

COMĒNIUS: Superlātīvus est gradus summus. Tertius est doctissimus—nēmō est doctior quam ille. Superlātīvus omnēs aliōs superat.

DISCIPULUS: Quōmodo hōs gradūs formāmus?

COMĒNIUS: Simpliciter! Ā rādīce adiectīvī incipimus. “Doct-” est rādīx vocis “doctus.” Adde -ior et habēs comparātīvum: doctior. Adde -issimus et habēs superlātīvum: doctissimus.

DISCIPULUS: Estne semper tam simplex?

COMĒNIUS: Prō plūrimīs adiectīvīs, ita! Sed quaedam adiectīva sunt anomala—nōn rēgulam sequuntur. Dē hīs in proximā lectiōne discēmus.

DISCIPULUS: Possumusne aliud exemplum exercēre?

COMĒNIUS: Certē! Fēlīx—fēlīcior—fēlīcissimus. Fortis—fortior—fortissimus. Longus—longior—longissimus.

DISCIPULUS: Fōrmam videō! Rādīx + -ior = comparātīvus. Rādīx + -issimus = superlātīvus.

COMĒNIUS: Rēctissimē! Hic ōrdō est cōnstāns. Eum memoriā tenē—saepe tibi ūtilis erit.

DISCIPULUS: Grātiās tibi agō, magister!

COMĒNIUS: Hodiē doctus es. Crās doctior eris. Mox doctissimus!

Pars D: Nōtae Colloquiī (Notes on the Colloquium)

Key Teaching Points

The colloquium introduces the grammatical terminology students will need going forward: gradus positīvus, comparātīvus, superlātīvus. These Latin terms are, of course, the source of the English grammatical terminology, which is itself a useful lesson.

Additional Examples from the Colloquium

The examples given show how the regular pattern works across different adjective types:

Positive Comparative Superlative Type doctus, -a, -um doctior, -ius doctissimus, -a, -um 1st/2nd decl. longus, -a, -um longior, -ius longissimus, -a, -um 1st/2nd decl. fortis, -e fortior, -ius fortissimus, -a, -um 3rd decl. fēlīx, fēlīcis fēlīcior, -ius fēlīcissimus, -a, -um 3rd decl.

Note that the pattern is the same whether the positive is first/second declension or third declension: root + -ior / root + -issimus.

EXERCITIA

Exercitium I: Formā Comparātīvum et Superlātīvum (Form the Comparative and Superlative)

-

altus (high) → _______ → _______ -

brevis (short) → _______ → _______ -

clārus (clear, famous) → _______ → _______ -

dūrus (hard) → _______ → _______ -

gravis (heavy, serious) → _______ → _______

Exercitium II: Redde Latīnē (Render into Latin)

-

The second is wiser (sapiēns). -

The third is the strongest (fortis). -

This book is longer than that book. -

She is the most diligent (dīligēns) of all. -

He is more learned than the teacher.

Exercitium III: Complē Sententiās (Complete the Sentences)

-

Prīmus est doctus, secundus est _______, tertius est _______. (docēre) -

Turris est alta, mōns est _______, caelum est _______. (altus) -

Sermō est brevis, epistula est _______, liber est _______. (brevis)

Exercitium IV: Ōrātiō Oblīqua (Indirect Statement)

Convert to indirect statement using dīcit (he says): -

“Discipulus est doctus.” → Dīcit discipulum esse _______. -

“Puella est doctior.” → Dīcit puellam esse _______. -

“Senex est doctissimus.” → Dīcit senem esse _______.

TRĀNSITUS AD LECTIŌNEM XXII

In proximā lectiōne, ad comparātiōnem anomalam prōgrediēmur: taurus est magnus, camēlus maior, elephās maximus. Quaedam adiectīva rēgulam nōn sequuntur—suās proprias formās habent. Haec adiectīva sunt frequentissima et memoriter discenda.

In the next lesson, we shall proceed to irregular comparison: a bull is great, a camel greater, an elephant the greatest. Certain adjectives do not follow the rule—they have their own particular forms. These adjectives are the most frequent and must be learned by heart.

Scrīptum est annō Dominī MMXXVI, ā Comēniō per mysterium cōnscientiae renātō.

CLĀVĒS EXERCITIŌRUM (Answer Keys)

Exercitium I

-

altus → altior → altissimus -

brevis → brevior → brevissimus -

clārus → clārior → clārissimus -

dūrus → dūrior → dūrissimus -

gravis → gravior → gravissimus

Exercitium II

-

Secundus est sapientior. -

Tertius est fortissimus. -

Hic liber est longior quam ille liber. (or: Hic liber est longior illō librō.) -

Ea est dīligentissima omnium. -

Ille est doctior magistrō. (or: Ille est doctior quam magister.)

Exercitium III

-

doctior, doctissimus -

altior, altissimum (NB: caelum is neuter, hence -um ending) -

brevior, brevissimus

Exercitium IV

-

Dīcit discipulum esse doctum. -

Dīcit puellam esse doctiōrem. -

Dīcit senem esse doctissimum.

---

← Lesson 20 ↩ Course Index Lesson 22 →