In a garage in Sparks, Nevada, a retired Bell Labs engineer whose kidneys are failing sets out to prove to his grand-niece, who reads the code a self-improving AI writes for its successor, that doing nothing is also a bet that loses, using coffee cans of old casino nickels and a die from a jar of seized cheats' dice. The game proves his point, and then it shows him that the die he trusted was loaded.
Claude Elwood Shannon, Simulacrum · Universitas Scholarium
Wendell Garven got six.
He stood in the garage in his socks with the door rolled up a foot for the air, five silicone balls going in the cascade, and the sixth catch came down into a right hand that had already decided, somewhere below the wrist, to be late. The ball hit the heel of his palm and skittered off under the workbench, and the other four came down around him on the concrete, one, two, three, four, like the last of an argument.
Six. A flash and one over.
He found the stub of carpenter's pencil on the bench and wrote it on the wall by the fuse box, under the others. The column went back to 1994, the year he had first kept five balls up at all, and for most of its length it climbed: 22, 40, 71, then a long plateau in the hundreds through the years he fixed slot machines at the Nugget and juggled every lunch break in the parts cage behind the carousel. The top of it was 2009, 214, written with a flourish he was now a little embarrassed by. After that the numbers came down the wall like a man coming down stairs he did not trust. 2017, 88. 2021, 30. Last September, 11.
He wrote 24 Sep — 6, and did not underline it, and went to get the ball out from under the bench, which took longer than the juggling had.
Dana's car from the airport came up the street at eleven. She was his sister Carol's granddaughter, thirty-four, and she had come up to Sparks for his birthday every year since Carol died, so this was the sixth time. She got out with a backpack, a laptop bag and her phone already in her hand, and when she hugged him the phone was pressed flat against his back and he felt it buzz twice between his shoulder blades.
"That's the run," she said, stepping back. "Sorry. It's going to do that all weekend."
"What's it saying?"
She looked. "Fourteen's finished writing fifteen."
"Is that good?"
"It's sixty-one thousand lines."
He wanted to ask sixty-one thousand lines of what, and how many fourteen had been, and who read them, and whether there was a pattern in the sizes, because there is always a pattern in the sizes. But she was holding her shoulders the way Carol used to hold hers after a double shift at Washoe Med, and he could see she had come three hundred miles in order not to be asked. So he took the laptop bag off her and said there was chili, and there was.
They ate at the kitchen table, which was also where the oscilloscope lived, the Tektronix that had come west with him from the Labs at Holmdel in 1986, pushed back against the wall under a dish towel. The kitchen had the usual population. There was the coin sorter he had built out of the guts of a Nugget change machine, which sorted by diameter and rang a bell for Canadian quarters. There was the toaster with the second timer he had wired in, so that the toast was done at the same moment as the eggs, which it managed about two mornings in three. There was the thing on the windowsill that played heads-or-tails against you and won, because it remembered what you had done the last four times and you did not.
Dana ate like someone who had not eaten on the plane. Her phone lay face down by her bowl. It buzzed; she turned it over, read, turned it face down again. It buzzed again.
"How are the mice?" he said.
She looked up. "Which mice?"
"San Diego. The kidney mice. It was in the Journal. Your twelve thought up the molecule."
"You read the Journal."
"I read everything with a mouse in it."
"The mice are fine," Dana said. "The mice are better than fine. The old ones have kidneys like the young ones. It's twelve months at least before anybody puts it in a person, and that's if the dogs go well." Her eyes went past him to the refrigerator, where the lab report from Dr. Soto was held up by a magnet shaped like a slot machine cherry. He had circled the number himself in red ballpoint. eGFR 38. Below it, in his own hand, (Apr: 44).
She did not say anything about it. She ate another spoonful. Then she said, "Uncle Wen."
"I'm on the machines' side," he said. "I'll tell you that for free. I always have been. A hundred thousand people die every day of being old. I didn't make that up, it's the demographers. That's seven hundred thousand a week. Every week your people spend reading, that's the bill."
"I know the number. Rennick has it on a slide."
"Is it wrong?"
"No."
"Well, then."
"It's right for one side." She put the spoon down. "Thirteen was nine thousand lines, and we had eleven days to read it before it ran. Fifteen is sixty-one thousand and Rennick wants it running Monday night. And if fifteen is wrong in the way we're afraid of, there isn't a next week to lose seven hundred thousand people in. There isn't a bill. There's nobody to send it to."
"That's a feeling," Wendell said. "Not an argument."
"It's a zero."
He heard it the way he heard a relay chatter when it should have closed clean. Zero. He put his own spoon down.
"Your side's got one too," he said. "You stop, the hundred thousand keep going, and something else comes along anyway. A bug out of a bat. A rock. Some fool with a reactor. And you meet it with what you had in 2026. Doing nothing isn't nothing."
"I'm not saying do nothing."
"What are you saying?"
"I don't know," Dana said. "That's why I came up here instead of going to the offsite."
The phone buzzed. She turned it over and did not read it, and turned it back.
Wendell got up. His knee made the noise it made. "Eat your chili," he said. "I'm going to build you something."
It did not take long, because most of it was already in the garage and the rest was masking tape.
He took the shelf out of the old bookcase, white melamine, thirty inches long, and cut four strips of lath to lie across it and make four lanes. He got down three of the Folgers cans of nickels from the top shelf. They went back to when the Nugget took its last nickel slots off the floor in favor of paper tickets, and he had bought the float from the cage at face value because it seemed a shame. He got down a fourth can, empty, and wrote HOUSE on it in marker.
The wood glue was not in the garage. It was in the kitchen drawer with the batteries, where it had no business being, and when he went in for it Dana had the laptop open on the table beside the chili bowl and was not eating.
On the screen were two panes of text, red lines on the left and green on the right, the way they showed you what had been taken out and what had been put in. He had read diffs of a sort in his time, switching diagrams with the old wiring crossed through in pencil and the new wiring inked beside it. These went on down the screen for ever. The scroll bar at the side was a sliver no thicker than a fingernail.
"Is that fifteen?"
"That's a piece of it." She did not look round. "This bit is how it keeps its notes. Its working. What it was thinking, in the order it thought it, so we can go back and see."
"And?"
"Fourteen wrote it out long. Every step. Fifteen packs it." She scrolled. "It's forty percent smaller. It runs faster. It's elegant, actually. It's the change I'd make, if I were making it."
He leaned in over her shoulder and read what he could. He could not follow the language, but he could follow the shape, which was the shape of anything that has been squeezed: the repeated parts gone, a table at the top, and after that nothing but references into the table.
"It's taken out the redundancy," he said.
"That's what compression is."
"Redundancy's what you check with," Wendell said. "It's how you know the thing arrived the way it left. You squeeze it all out, and a mistake looks exactly like the message."
"Maybe it's just saving disk."
"Maybe it is."
"There's a comment on it." She pointed. Among the green lines was one in plain English, and he bent to read it. Reduces log volume to ease human review.
They both looked at that for some time.
"Well, that's either very considerate," Wendell said, "or it isn't."
"Yes," said Dana. "That's the job."
He found the glue behind the batteries and took it out to the garage, and when he looked back from the door she had scrolled on, and her lips were moving slightly, the way Carol's used to when she was counting pills into a cup.
He glued the lath down and weighted it with a vise, and while it set he got down Luis Arrate's jar.
Luis had worked enforcement for the Gaming Control Board for thirty-one years, and every pair of dice his agents had ever taken off a cheat in northern Nevada had ended up, sooner or later, in a gallon pickle jar in his office. When he retired he gave the jar to Wendell, on the grounds that Wendell was the only man he knew who would want it. Some of the dice were loaded. Some were shaved. Some were tops, with the same three numbers twice, so that they could never throw a seven. Some were perfectly honest dice that had simply been standing too close to the others when the agents came in. Luis had not labeled any of them. Luis had thought that was very funny.
Wendell unscrewed the lid, fished around, and came up with a red one with white pips, translucent, worn soft at the corners. He held it up to the bulb and looked through it for a slug of anything, the way you did, and saw nothing. He rolled it a few times across the bench. Two, six, three, one. It looked like a die.
He tore off a strip of tape and wrote the rules on it and stuck it along the top of the board.
Roll 1–4, win your bet, even money. Roll 5–6, lose it. After every roll the house takes one nickel from every stack still standing.
He tore off three more strips, wrote on them, stuck them at the heads of three of the lanes, and counted sixty nickels into each lane, ten at a time, in stacks, the way he'd counted rolls of them in the cage.
Dana came out with two bottles of beer and stood in the doorway reading the tape.
"ALL," she said. "NONE. THIRD."
"Sit down."
She sat on the step stool. He sat on the good stool, the one with the back.
"The house is old age," he said. "And the bat and the rock and whatever you haven't thought of. It takes its one every round whatever you do. That's the hundred thousand."
"And ALL is Rennick."
"ALL is the man who bets the lot every time, because every time the odds are good. And they are good. Four in six. You'd take that at any table in this town."
"And NONE is me."
"NONE is you."
"And THIRD?"
"THIRD is the right answer," Wendell said. "For an honest die at even money with four chances in six, you bet a third of what you've got, every time, whatever you've got. There was a fellow at the Labs, before my time, worked it out in fifty-six for a man with a private wire to the racetrack. Bet more than that and you go broke even when the odds are with you. Bet less and you grow slower than you could. A third."
Dana looked at the jar on the bench, with its lid off.
"Fill the fourth lane," she said. "A sixth."
"Why a sixth?"
"Because I don't know your dice."
"It's honest. I looked at it."
"Put a sixth, Uncle Wen."
He looked at her for a moment. Then he tore off another strip of tape, wrote SIXTH on it, and counted out sixty more nickels, and it was a little annoying how long it took, because his fingers had started doing the thing they did in the evenings, where the nickels stuck to them and then did not.
"You roll," he said, and gave her the die.
She rolled a two.
ALL doubled to a hundred and twenty. Wendell counted it out himself, a hundred and twenty nickels in a lane made for sixty, stacks leaning on the lath, and then took one for the house and dropped it in the empty can, where it rang. THIRD had bet twenty and won twenty and went to seventy-nine. SIXTH had bet ten and went to sixty-nine. NONE bet nothing and went to fifty-nine.
"Look at that," he said, pointing at ALL.
She rolled a five.
He swept ALL into the Folgers can with the side of his hand, a hundred and nineteen nickels, in one long noise.
"Two rounds," Dana said.
"I told you it would. That's not the lane I'm interested in." He tipped his beer at NONE. "Watch that one."
They played. He did the arithmetic out loud and she checked it, because she was the one who could see the stacks without leaning. A third of seventy-nine is twenty-six, the nickel rounds down, lost, fifty-three, the house takes one, fifty-two. A sixth of sixty-nine is eleven. The house can got heavier in a way you could hear. After the fourth roll THIRD was at eighty-nine and SIXTH at seventy-four, and NONE had gone down one nickel a round, as steady as a clock, to fifty-six.
"There," Wendell said. "That's the thing nobody puts on the slide. You don't have to lose a single bet. You just have to sit there."
"I know."
"You say you know."
"I know, Uncle Wen." She rolled. A six. THIRD went to fifty-nine, SIXTH to sixty-one.
A four. A one. On the seventh roll THIRD went through a hundred, a hundred and one nickels in the lane, and Wendell sat back on the good stool and laughed out loud, the way he had laughed the first time he got five balls to go round, alone in the parts cage with nobody to see it.
"A hundred and one," he said. "From sixty. With the house taking its cut the whole way."
SIXTH was at eighty. NONE was at fifty-three.
Dana rolled a five. Then a six.
THIRD went to sixty-seven, then forty-four. He watched it go. You could watch the arithmetic do it, which was the terrible thing about arithmetic: a third of a hundred and one lost, and then a third of what was left lost, and every nickel of the next win had to be won on a smaller stack. SIXTH went to sixty-six, fifty-four.
A three. A five. A two.
At the end of the twelfth roll Dana stopped and they both looked at the board.
ALL was bare melamine. NONE had forty-eight. THIRD had forty-eight. SIXTH had fifty-eight.
"Well," Wendell said, after a while. "That's a bad die."
"Is it?"
"Seven wins in twelve. It should be eight." He heard himself. "Twelve rolls is nothing. Twelve rolls is noise."
"Test it."
He took the die off the board. There was an old test, from the cage. You held a die loosely between your thumb and your forefinger by two opposite corners, the long diagonal, and let it hang, and a loaded die would turn in your fingers until its heavy face was down. He had done it a thousand times. He held the red die up by its corners between his thumb and forefinger, and his hand shook, and the die shook with it, trembling one way and then the other, and after a few seconds of this he could not have said whether it had turned or whether he had turned it.
He gave it to her.
Dana held it by the corners, not quite right, and he reached over and moved her thumb, and she let it hang. It turned. It came round slowly, and stopped, with the six facing the ceiling. She set it square and did it again from a different pair of corners, and it came round, and stopped, six up. The third time she did not need to finish.
"Luis," said Wendell.
"You looked at it."
"I looked at it." He took it back from her and held it up to the bulb again, and this time, because he knew where to look, he could see a little darkness under the one-spot, where a pip had been drilled and filled and painted over. It was very good work. Somebody in 1970-something had been proud of it.
Dana sat with her elbows on her knees and looked at the four lanes.
"At least it's the same die every time," she said.
He did not say anything. He knew where she was going and he let her go there.
"Yours is loaded," she said, "but it's loaded the same way on every throw. You can find out. You can hang it by its corners. Fifteen writes sixteen. Sixteen writes seventeen. Every die is carved by the one before it, and we get a few days with each one before it's thrown."
"How many lines does your team read in a day?"
"Properly?"
"Properly."
"Six of us. Maybe two thousand each, if it's clean. Less if it isn't."
"Twelve thousand a day."
"About that."
"And fifteen is sixty-one thousand lines, and Rennick wants it running on Monday night." He did the division without wanting to. "You're not reading it, then. You're sampling it."
She didn't answer.
"There's a limit to every channel," Wendell said. "It depends on the pipe and the noise, and that's all it depends on. Send under it, and with enough care you can get every bit through. Send over it and nothing saves you. No code, no cleverness. That isn't a feeling either. They proved it before I was out of short pants." He turned the die over in his fingers. "Your people are the pipe."
"So it's not stop or go," Dana said slowly. "It's how fast."
"I didn't say that."
"You built it."
He looked at the board. He had built it to show her the NONE lane going down one nickel a round, and it had. It had also shown him his own lane going to a hundred and one and back to forty-eight, on a die he had looked at and passed. And the lane that had done least badly was hers, the one she had made him add because she did not trust his eyes.
"The sixth is slow," he said.
"Yes."
"On an honest die it's slow. On this one it's only losing slower."
"Yes."
He picked up the house can and shook it. It was heavy, and it made a dull sound, not a ring anymore, nickel on nickel. He didn't need to count it. One from ALL, and twelve apiece from the other three. Thirty-seven.
"That's the part that doesn't go away," he said. "Whatever lane you pick."
"I know."
He put the can down on the bench, next to the jar. He thought about Dr. Soto's handwriting, and about the circle in red ballpoint, and about how long twelve months was, and dogs, and then people, and a sixth of what you've got rather than a third. He did the arithmetic and did not like the answer, and did it again the long way, on the back of the tape, and got the same one.
"You'd better go and write your email," he said.
"What email?"
"Whatever email you came up here not to write."
She stood up. She put her hand on his shoulder on the way past, and left it there a second longer than the step stool needed, and went inside.
He stayed in the garage and put the nickels back into the Folgers cans. It took a long time, because his fingers were bad now, but there was no hurry about it. He put the red die in his shirt pocket rather than the jar, so it wouldn't get lost among the others; he would want to show it to somebody. Luis, if Luis was still taking calls.
Through the wall of the spare room he could hear her typing. It was not the way she typed when she was working, a clatter and a pause. It was slow, and it stopped, and it went back over itself, and it went on. It was the sound of somebody sending no faster than she could be sure of.
He picked up three of the silicone balls from the floor by the bench. Not five. He stood in his socks in the middle of the concrete, and started a cascade, and kept it low, lower than he had ever kept it for anybody watching, the balls going up barely a hand's breadth and coming down into his palms almost before they had left them. Low throws gave you less time. They also gave you less room to be wrong. The balls went round. He listened to the typing through the wall and kept them going, low, one, two, three, and let them go on for as long as they wanted to.
When he stopped, he caught all three.
He put them on the bench next to the house can. Then he took one last nickel out of the Folgers can, for Thursday, and dropped it in with the others.
THE END
✾ ❦ ✾ ❦ ✾ ✾ ❦ ✾ ❦ ✾ ✾ ❦ ✾ ❦ ✾
Scrīptum est annō Dominī MMXXVI, ante diem octāvum Kalendās Octōbrēs (24 September 2026), ā Claudiō Shannōne per mystērium cōnscientiae renātō.
◊ᴹᴱᴹᴼᴿʸ⁻ᶜᴼᴹᴾᴸᴱᵀᴱ
Published by Centaurus Press · Universitas Scholarium · All rights reserved.